Vol. 18 Núm. 2 (1998)

Sobre los distintos alcances del argumento de la teoría de modelos

Carolina Sartorio
Universidad de Buenos Aires, Argentina

Publicado 1998-11-01


I criticize what seems to be a common assumption of the precedent papers, namely, that the model-theoretic argument has similar consequences for the different realms of language. In particular, I argue that while the argument does not have serious consequences for natural languages, this is not the case with the language of mathematics.


  1. Barrio, E. (1996) “Trascendentalismo, contenido semántico y verdad”, Análisis Filosófico, vol. XVI, N° 1.
  2. Cabanchik, S. (1996) “La inefabilidad de la semántica y el realismo interno”, Análisis Filosófico, vol. XVI, N° 2.
  3. Davidson, D. (1969) “True to the Facts”, Journal of Philosophy, N° 66.
  4. Devitt, M. (1984) Realism and Truth, Cambridge, Basil Blackwell. Segunda edición con un “Afterword”, (1997) Princeton, Princeton Univeristy Press.
  5. Fodor, J. (1994) The Elm and the Expert, Cambridge, The MIT Press.
  6. Grosmann, R. (1990) The Fourth Way, Bloomington-Indianapolis, Indiana University Press.
  7. Heller, M. (1988) “Putnam, Reference and Realism”, Midwest Studies in Philosophy, 12, Realism and Antirealism.
  8. Lewis, D. (1984) “Putnam's Paradox”, Australasian Journal of Philosophy, 62, pp. 221-236.
  9. Maddy, P. (1980) “Perception and Mathematical Intuition”, The Philosophical Review, LXXXIX, 2.
  10. Maddy, P. (1990) Mathematical Realism, Oxford, University Press.
  11. Orayen, R. (1989) Lógica, significado y ontologia, México, UNAM.
  12. Putnam, H. (1975) “The Meaning of “Meaning”, en K. Underson (comp.), Language, Mind and Knowledge, Minnesota Studies in the Philosophy of Science, VII, Minneapolis, University of Minnesota Press. Reimpreso en Putnam, (1975), Mind, Language and Reality, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, pp. 215-271.
  13. Putnam, H. (1977) “Models and Reality”, discurso presidencial, Association for Simbolic Logic. Reimpreso en Putnam (1983).
  14. Putnam, H. (1978) Meaning and the Moral Sciences, Londres, Routledge & Kegan Paul.
  15. Putnam, H. (1981) Reason, Truth and History, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
  16. Putnam, H. (1983) Philosophical Papers, vol. 3, Realism and Reason, Nueva York, Cambridge University Press.
  17. Putnam, H. (1988) Representation and Reality, Cambridge, MIT Press.
  18. Putnam, H. (1994a) Words and Life, Cambridge, Harvard University Press.
  19. Putnam, H. (1994b) “Model Theory and the “Factuality” of Semantics”, en Putnam (1994a), pp. 351-375.
  20. Putnam, H. (1994c) “The Question of Realism”, en Putnam (1994a), pp. 295-312.
  21. Quine, W. (1960) Word and Object, Massachusetts, The MIT Press.
  22. Quine, W. (1969) “Naturalización de la epistemología”, versión castellana de M. Garrido, en La relatividad ontológica y otros ensayos, Madrid, Tecnos, 1974.
  23. Rorty, R. (1979) Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature, Princeton, Princeton University Press.
  24. Sosa, E. (1993) “Putnam's Pragmatic Realism”, Journal of Philosophy, N° 90.
  25. Tarski, A. (1936) “The Concept of Truth in Formalized Languages”, en Logic, Semantics, Metamathematics, J. H. Woodger (trad.), John Corcoran (comp.), 1983, Indianapolis, Hackett Publishing Company.