Published 2014-05-01
Keywords
- Referencia,
- Individuación,
- Determinación
- Reference,
- Individuation,
- Determination
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Abstract
Fregeans follow Frege (1892) in accepting informativeness and substitution failure as reliable criteria for the existence of senses as objects of thought. In this paper I show that if we accept this, we must also accept the existence of an infinite hierarchy of senses as objects of thought. This is a bad result since it turns Fregeanism into a doctrine according to which object-related thoughts either have an infinite number of objects as contents or none at all. This shows, against the Fregean, that senses cannot themselves be constituents of thought.
References
1. Carlson, G. (2004), "Reference", in Horn, L. and Ward, G. (eds.) (2004), The Handbook of Pragmatics, Oxford, Blackwell.
2. Carnap, R. (1947), Meaning and Necessity, Chicago, University of Chicago Press.
3. Chalmers, D. (2002), "On sense and intension", in Tomberlin, J. (ed.) (2002), Philosophical Perspectives, 16, Language and Mind, pp. 135-182.
4. Chalmers, D. (2004), "Epistemic Two-dimensional semantics", Philosophical Studies, 118 (1), pp. 153-226.
5. Cummings, S. (2009), "Names", in Zalta, E. (ed.) Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
6. Evans, G. (1982), The Varieties of Reference, Oxford, Oxford University Press.
7. Devitt, M. (1981), Designation, New York, Columbia University Press.
8. Dummett, M. (1973), Frege: Philosophy of Language, London, Harper & Row Publishers.
9. Dummett, M. (1991), The Logical Basis of Metaphysics, Cambridge, Harvard University Press.
10. Fitch, G. and Nelson, M. (2007), "Singular propositions", in Zalta, E. (ed.) Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
11. Frege, G. (1892), "On Sense and Nominatum", in Martinich, A.P. (ed.) (2002), The Philosophy of Language, Oxford, Oxford University Press.
12. Heim, I. and Kratzer, A. (1998), Semantics in Generative Grammar, Oxford, Basil Blackwell.
13. Jackson, F. (1998), From Metaphysics to Ethics, Oxford, Oxford University Press.
14. McDowell, J. (1977), "On the sense and reference of a proper name", Mind, 86 (342), pp. 159-185.
15. McDowell, J. (1984), "De re senses", The Philosophical Quarterly, 34 (136), pp. 283-294.
16. Plantinga, A. (1978), "The boethian compromise", in Plantinga, A. (2003), Essays in the Metaphysics of Modality, Oxford, Oxford University Press.
17. Recanati, F. (1993), Direct Reference, Oxford, Blackwell.
18. Recanati, F. (2010), "Singular thought: in defense of acquaintance", in Jeshion, R. (ed.) (2010), New Essays on Singular Thought, Oxford, Oxford University Press.
19. Salmon, N. (1986), Frege's Puzzle, Cambridge, The MIT Press.
20. Stanley, J. (1997), "Names and rigid designation" in Hale, B. and Wright, C. (eds.) (1997), A Companion to the Philosophy of Language, Oxford, Blackwell Publishing.
2. Carnap, R. (1947), Meaning and Necessity, Chicago, University of Chicago Press.
3. Chalmers, D. (2002), "On sense and intension", in Tomberlin, J. (ed.) (2002), Philosophical Perspectives, 16, Language and Mind, pp. 135-182.
4. Chalmers, D. (2004), "Epistemic Two-dimensional semantics", Philosophical Studies, 118 (1), pp. 153-226.
5. Cummings, S. (2009), "Names", in Zalta, E. (ed.) Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
6. Evans, G. (1982), The Varieties of Reference, Oxford, Oxford University Press.
7. Devitt, M. (1981), Designation, New York, Columbia University Press.
8. Dummett, M. (1973), Frege: Philosophy of Language, London, Harper & Row Publishers.
9. Dummett, M. (1991), The Logical Basis of Metaphysics, Cambridge, Harvard University Press.
10. Fitch, G. and Nelson, M. (2007), "Singular propositions", in Zalta, E. (ed.) Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
11. Frege, G. (1892), "On Sense and Nominatum", in Martinich, A.P. (ed.) (2002), The Philosophy of Language, Oxford, Oxford University Press.
12. Heim, I. and Kratzer, A. (1998), Semantics in Generative Grammar, Oxford, Basil Blackwell.
13. Jackson, F. (1998), From Metaphysics to Ethics, Oxford, Oxford University Press.
14. McDowell, J. (1977), "On the sense and reference of a proper name", Mind, 86 (342), pp. 159-185.
15. McDowell, J. (1984), "De re senses", The Philosophical Quarterly, 34 (136), pp. 283-294.
16. Plantinga, A. (1978), "The boethian compromise", in Plantinga, A. (2003), Essays in the Metaphysics of Modality, Oxford, Oxford University Press.
17. Recanati, F. (1993), Direct Reference, Oxford, Blackwell.
18. Recanati, F. (2010), "Singular thought: in defense of acquaintance", in Jeshion, R. (ed.) (2010), New Essays on Singular Thought, Oxford, Oxford University Press.
19. Salmon, N. (1986), Frege's Puzzle, Cambridge, The MIT Press.
20. Stanley, J. (1997), "Names and rigid designation" in Hale, B. and Wright, C. (eds.) (1997), A Companion to the Philosophy of Language, Oxford, Blackwell Publishing.